|
In the previous 50 columns
(which originally ran in Ohio Lawyers Weekly),
I have preached the gospel of Plain English.
What exactly is Plain English, and how does it
translate to legal writing? This will be new to
new readers, a recap for some.
The Plain English movement is
simply this: write in the most readable manner
for your audience to understand. That doesn't
sound difficult, but as lawyers, we have fallen
into bad habits, many of which are hard to
break. At minimum, though, you can improve your
writing by making some elementary changes:
Shorter sentence length.
Sentence length is the first major element of
readability. Sentences should average no more
than 18 words, and never go over 35. One
exception to the 35-word limit: lists.
-
Fewer passive sentences.
Active voice is another element of
readability. We talk in the active voice.
Sometimes passive is unavoidable, but
usually not. Write the court reversed the
judgment, rather than the judgment
was reversed.
-
Fewer verbs turned into
nouns. Question words ending in -tion
or -ment. Some simply cover up
perfectly good verbs. How about "Smith
Company determined, rather than
"made a determination?"
"The plan improved the
roadway," rather than "resulted
in an improvement?" Or you "moved
for summary judgment," not "filed
a motion?" Putting nominalizations
back into verbs greatly improves your
writing, saving not only words, but also
awkward constructions.
-
Shorter paragraphs. We
tend to run on and on. There is no specific
rule, but don't ever go more than a half
page - the reader has to see when it's safe
to take a break.
-
More headings. Headings
are signposts for the reader. And we should
use them for the same reason as writing
shorter sentences and shorter paragraphs,
with the additional benefit of imparting
information. Instead of Facts or Argument
write The Fire and the Aftermath or No
Miranda Violation.
-
Easily readable
typefaces. Stop using Times New Roman. It
was designed for newsprint, where the ink
expands. But our laser printers print the
periods and commas too small. Never use
Courier - it's the most unreadable typeface.
Use Georgia or Palatino - those are the best
that everyone has on their PC. Use Arial or
Verdana for headings, but not text.
-
One word, not three. The
goofy couplets, null and void, fit
and proper, will and testament, sell
and convey, due and payable,
haven't been necessary for almost a thousand
years, but we forgot to change.
-
Purge lawspeak. Hereinafter,
Aforesaid, Thereinafter, Whereas,
and the like are banned, unless you are
trying to be funny. And kill the
parenthetical numericals, as in one (1).
They can only get you in trouble. If the
numbers and letters conflict, the words
control - but the numbers are more likely to
be right!
These are just a few
quick ways to make your writing better. You
can find a more in-depth discussion of all
the above, plus more, in The Legal
Writer: 40 Rules for the Art of Legal
Writing.
Readability
I always show the readability
scores for the column. Statistics for this
column (excepting the quotes, of course, which
are unintelligible): 11 words per sentence, 3
percent passive voice, and grade level 8.8.
____________________________________
Mark
Painter has served as
a judge on the Ohio First District Court of Appeals
for 12 years, after 13 years on the Hamilton County
Municipal Court. He has taught as an Adjunct Professor
at the University of Cincinnati College of Law since
1990. Judge Painter
has given dozens of seminars on legal writing. Contact
him through his website, www.judgepainter.org
|